Federal Court hearings examine whether Canada’s Safe Third Country Agreement violates equality rights protected under the Charter.

Hearings began in Toronto on November 9, 2026, with refugee advocacy organizations arguing that the agreement discriminates against vulnerable asylum seekers.

The challenge involves Amnesty International Canada, the Canadian Council for Refugees, the Canadian Council of Churches and former refugee claimants.

The applicants argue that returning certain asylum seekers to the United States violates Section 15 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

How the Safe Third Country Agreement Works

Canada and the United States signed the agreement in December 2002, and it took effect on December 29, 2004.

Under the agreement, refugee claimants must generally seek protection in the first safe country they enter.

People arriving from the United States at Canadian land border crossings may be returned unless they qualify for an exception.

In March 2023, Canada expanded the agreement across the land border, including internal waterways. It also covers certain people who cross between official border points and request protection within 14 days.

Why Refugee Advocates Are Challenging the Agreement

The applicants argue that the agreement disproportionately affects racialized women, LGBTQI+ individuals and children.

They maintain that some asylum seekers returned to the United States could experience immigration detention, inadequate protection or deportation to countries where they face persecution.

Their challenge focuses on Section 15 of the Charter, which protects individuals against discrimination.

The organizations want the Federal Court to strike down the designation of the United States as a safe third country.

These arguments remain allegations before the court, not established constitutional findings.

Why the Case Has Returned to Court

The legal dispute has continued through Canadian courts for several years.

In 2023, the Supreme Court of Canada returned the agreement’s Section 15 equality questions to the Federal Court for further consideration.

Hearings were scheduled for November 9, 10 and 12, with another session planned for December 16, 2026.

The court will examine the evidence before determining whether the agreement violates constitutional equality protections.

Does the Agreement Still Apply?

The Safe Third Country Agreement remains operational while the challenge proceeds.

Canada continues applying its existing rules to refugee claimants arriving from the United States.

Exceptions may apply to individuals with qualifying family members in Canada, eligible unaccompanied minors, certain Canadian document holders and specific public interest circumstances.

However, qualifying for an exception does not automatically guarantee refugee protection.

Applicants must still satisfy other immigration and asylum eligibility requirements.

What Could Happen Next?

A ruling favouring the applicants could affect how Canada applies the agreement, depending on the remedy ordered and any subsequent appeals.

If the challenge fails, the current designation could remain unchanged, subject to further legal proceedings.

For now, refugee claimants should follow existing Canadian border requirements.

Anyone considering a refugee claim should review official Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada guidance and seek qualified legal advice before making decisions.

Share this article

Related Posts

Canada PR and Citizenship Processing Times Hold Steady
October 16, 2026 Immigration to Canada Come to Canada Canada Immigration Life in Canada Immigrate to Canada Canada Immigration Current News Canada Immigration News Today Canada and Immigration News Canada Immigration news Immigration Policy Economic Immigration Work in Canada Canada Permanent Residence Family Sponsorship Provincial Nominee Programs (PNP) Express Entry
Mark Carney Confirms Immigration Cut and New Plan Coming Soon
October 21, 2025 Mark Carney immigration plan 2025
IRCC Cuts Work Permit Waits as Study Permit Delays Rise
November 05, 2026 Immigration to Canada Come to Canada Canada Immigration Life in Canada Immigrate to Canada Canada Immigration Current News Canada Immigration News Today Canada and Immigration News Canada Immigration news Immigration Policy Immigrate to Canada from India Immigrate to Canada from Nigeria Immigrate to Canada from Pakistan Immigrate to Canada from the Philippines Work in Canada
IRCC Updates PR, Family and Citizenship Processing Times
August 12, 2026 Immigration to Canada Come to Canada Canada Immigration Life in Canada Immigrate to Canada Canada Immigration Current News Canada Immigration News Today Canada and Immigration News Canada Immigration news Immigration Policy Economic Immigration Work in Canada Canada Permanent Residence Family Sponsorship Quebec Immigration Provincial Nominee Programs (PNP) Express Entry Atlantic Immigration Pilot Federal Skilled Trades Program (FSTP) Super Visa for Parents and Grandparents Parents and Grandparents Sponsorship IRCC Canadian Experience Class (CEC)
Canada Offers New PRRA Chance to Israelis, Palestinians
October 03, 2026 Immigration to Canada Come to Canada Canada Immigration Life in Canada Immigrate to Canada Canada Immigration Current News Canada Immigration News Today Canada and Immigration News Canada Immigration news Immigration Policy IRCC
Canada to Change Hours at 26 Border Crossings This November
October 14, 2026 Immigration to Canada Come to Canada Canada Immigration Life in Canada Immigrate to Canada Canada Immigration Current News Canada Immigration News Today Canada and Immigration News Canada Immigration news Immigration Policy
Canada’s New Asylum Rules Bring 60-Day Filing Deadline
November 9, 2026 Immigration to Canada Come to Canada Canada Immigration Life in Canada Immigrate to Canada Canada Immigration Current News Canada Immigration News Today Canada and Immigration News Canada Immigration news Immigration Policy IRCC
Canada Cuts Immigration Application Inventory by 35,180
November 18, 2026 Immigration to Canada Come to Canada Canada Immigration Life in Canada Immigrate to Canada Canada Immigration Current News Canada Immigration News Today Canada and Immigration News Canada Immigration news Immigration Policy Economic Immigration Work in Canada Study in Canada Canada Permanent Residence Family Sponsorship Visitor Visa Provincial Nominee Programs (PNP) Express Entry Atlantic Immigration Pilot Open Work Permits Canada Study Permit PR Pathways for Temporary Workers Super Visa for Parents and Grandparents Parents and Grandparents Sponsorship IRCC